Personal and Commercial Insurance | Melville, NY | First Heritage Insurance Agency

Testimonials

I've been looking for a general liability insurance policy for my nonprofit organization for over 2 weeks. I was being bounced around from different carriers, looking to get a quote, several carriers weren't returning emails. Until Marie from First Heritage Insurance Agency called me and was able to get me a quote, collect payment and make an endorsement to the policy all within minutes. She is extremely professional and I'm looking forward with working with her and First Heritage Insurance Agency going forward. Thanks Marie!

Customer: Sky K.

Agent: Marie Alfieri

Got dropped by my insurance company and had to search for new insurance. I had the pleasure of dealing with Tiffany. She helped me beyond expectations and even after hours since my insurance was expiring that same day and I didn't want a lapse in coverage. She quoted me $5,000 cheaper than my previous broker for the same insurance who I was with for many years and with multiple insurances. Thank you so much.

Customer: Murad S.

Agent: Tiffany Gardella

I have been searching for limited liability insurance for quite a while now and the only quotes I could find for my business were upwards of $1,000. I was ready to give up until I spoke with Marie Alfieri from First Heritage. I don't' recall the last time I spoke with a customer service rep who was so motivated to help me! She was friendly and easy going. Initially she could only find a quote that wasn't in my budget. I hung up disappointed. A few minutes later she called me back- she had done more research and found a policy for 1/10th of the cost! She processed it immediately and I thought we were good to go. Unfortunately, on of my providers needed super specific details added to the policy. After every change was made they would email me with another requirement. Throughout this process Marie was patient and understanding and even though it was a supreme annoyance- got everything done in less than an hour. Highly recommend!

Customer: Z Shapiro

Agent: Marie Alfieri

My agent was Brandon Blood and boy did he jump through some hoops for my mother. She had just moved, was in the hospital and her previous policy had lapsed. In other words, it was a mess. Brandon was able to walk us through every step we needed, I would definitely see Brandon for any insurance needs!! Thank you again Brandon 👍🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

Customer: Brain R.

Agent: Brandon Blood

Their team helped me within an find a great quote exactly what I needed, sent over all my information quickly. I seriously couldn't be happier! Seriously if you're looking for a policy give them a call you will not be disappointed!

Customer: Michael G

I can’t say enough great things about my experience with these guys! Big shout out to Bradley as he went above and beyond to make sure I got all paperwork down to the last letter done properly. Not to mention he helped out making sure that the right parties got whatever they need to get concerning my insurance. Super super appreciative of the quality and care they showed especially now when times are crazy. 🙏🙏🙏

Customer: Luis M.

Agent: Bradley Krill

In my humble and honest opinion, Mr. Brandon Blood is the best person I ever met in insurance business he took care of all of my problems and issues with laughter and grace. I pray that others bump into him along their way. I have two vehicles insured through first Heritage. I would only go to first Heritage with many more God willing commercial and personal insurance.

Customer: D James

Agent: Brandon Blood

Who We ArePlay The Movie

Reliable Personal and Commercial Insurance Coverage

As a digital agency, First Heritage Insurance Agency provides forward-thinking solutions for all of your personal and commercial insurance needs through our convenient online services. Our satisfied customers trust us to help them find the best possible coverage at rates they can afford. We’re also happy to spend as much time as you need finding and comparing rates until you come to a confident decision. We serve clients throughout New York, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Florida & New Jersey.

Our Insurance Services

Whether you’re currently uninsured or you’re just looking to switch providers, our team can assist you. The team at our agency lives and works in your community. We are dedicated to searching rates from several trusted carriers to find you the best insurance policies based on your needs and budget. We have many qualified agents available to help you via phone or email, making it easy for you to fit finding reliable insurance coverage into your busy life. Know someone who needs insurance? Tell your friends and family about us, and you can both save money! Get your free quote online today.

Auto Insurance

When you need the protection of auto insurance, we’re here to help. Car accidents, damage to vehicles, and vehicular injuries can rack up enormous expenses. From basic policies to full coverage, we’ll find the insurance you need to keep you safe both under the law and in case of an accident.

Home Insurance

Our homes are more than just the places we live; they’re the centers of our families’ lives. Just as each home is different from the next, insurance policies can vary, as well. We’ll work with you to determine the best type of home insurance coverage you need for your house, condo, or rental property, including your assets and personal belongings.

Business Insurance

We’re a small business, so we understand the need to protect yours. We use our knowledge and expertise in this field to find affordable business insurance policies for your changing and growing business, including those for property damage, employee protection, and legal liabilities.