Our Service Area

Insurance Agency Serving All of Long Island

Local expertise in Nassau County, Suffolk County, and across New York since 2003

Our Service Areas Across Long Island

Since 2003, First Heritage Insurance Agency has served families and businesses across Nassau County, Suffolk County, and all of Long Island. Whether you’re in Melville, Huntington, Hauppauge, or anywhere in between, you get the same local expertise and personalized service that’s made us a trusted name in New York insurance.

We know Long Island. We understand the risks that come with coastal weather, busy highways like the LIE and Northern State, and the unique needs of local businesses. That local knowledge means better coverage recommendations and faster service when you need it most.

Every location gets access to our full range of insurance services, commercial auto and fleet coverage, business insurance, home and high-value property protection, and personal auto policies. We work with top-rated carriers to compare options and find the right fit for your situation, no matter where you’re located.

20+ Years Serving Long Island | Licensed in 5 States

1,500+ Five-Star Reviews | Same-Day Quotes Available

Where We Serve

Suffolk County Insurance Agency

Protecting families and businesses from Hauppauge to Montauk and everywhere in between. We understand Suffolk County's unique insurance needs, from coastal windstorm coverage for waterfront properties to specialized fleet insurance for local businesses. Our team serves Huntington, Babylon, Smithtown, and all Suffolk County communities with fast quotes, expert guidance, and dedicated local support.

Nassau County Insurance Agency

Comprehensive insurance coverage for families and businesses across Garden City, Hempstead, Mineola, Hicksville, and all Nassau County communities. Whether you need commercial auto for your fleet, home insurance for your property, or business coverage for your company, our Melville office serves all of Nassau County with personalized service and competitive rates from top carriers.

Major Long Island Communities We Serve

From Melville to Montauk, our team knows Long Island inside and out. We serve families and businesses in every major community with the same level of personalized service, local expertise, and access to top-rated carriers. No matter which city you call home, you get fast quotes, dedicated agent support, and comprehensive coverage for all your insurance needs.

Also Licensed to Serve: Connecticut | New Jersey | Pennsylvania | Florida

Partners & Affiliations

We partner with some of the most respected insurance carriers in the industry to bring you reliable coverage and peace of mind.

Locations